One Stanley is worth a hundred good books.
•Anton Chekov, obituary for Nikolai Przhevalsky (1888).
“Dr. Livingstone, I presume,” Henry Morton Stanley said when, deep in the uncharted wilds of Africa, he finally found the celebrity missionary he was looking for. David Livingstone had been missing for years, his once-frequent updates on his African adventures having trickled to nothing. People were worried. Stanley, a no-name reporter for the New York Herald, somehow managed the apparently impossible feat of locating one man in the middle of a continent. The dispatches Stanley filed for the Herald made him famous. They also made him immortal, in the sense that there are very few Victorian reporters everyone knows; and everyone knows Stanley. His lapidary “Dr. Livingstone, I presume” is every bit as famous as Stanley himself. I learned the phrase as a small child from a Porky Pig cartoon (watch it here). It’s a Moody Blues song (hear it here). A 1977 joke book about “the war between the sexists” [sic] suggests that “women’s libbers” would like to see classic quotations updated, and renders Stanley’s phrase: “Mrs. Livingstone, I presume?” (attributed here to “Henrietta M. Stanley”). It’s everywhere.

Mungo Park or John Hanning Speke are probably not household names, and yet they were also great African explorers of the 1800s. Stanley, though, we remember. It’s that phrase, “Dr. Livingstone, I presume,” that has taken a life of its own and kept Stanley’s memory alive.
“Dr. Livingstone, I presume.” Stanley probably never said it; and it made him the laughingstock of the day.
ii. I’m not claiming necessarily that the nineteenth century was the golden age of cruel, mocking catchphrases, but it certainly wasn’t a lag time. “Dr. Livingstone, I presume” was the risible toast of the town in an England that had already grown tired of shouting “Oh, what a shocking bad hat you have got!” and, before that, “No mi ricordo” (a line spoken by an Italian witness eighty-seven times running at a sensational royal divorce trial— “it was set to music and sung in imitation of a comic Italian tenor,” reports Paul Johnson).
And then there was “Dr. Livingstone, I presume.” No one believed he said it. Or, the few people who believed he said it hated the fact that he said it. Stanley had done something remarkable, and all people wanted to talk about was what a goon and/or liar he’d been as he’d done it.
The only witness for the famous “presumption” is Stanley. Livingstone didn’t mention it in his journals or voluminous letters. Stanley’s travel diary has the page detailing the meeting torn out. Stanley certainly claimed to have uttered “Dr. Livingstone, I presume,” but he didn’t make the claim until he was far from Livingstone, filing a Herald story while sitting at a desk in Zanzibar.
People hated “Dr. Livingstone, I presume” because it sounded like a parody of the formal phlegmatic English gentleman, unruffled even on the shores of Lake Tanganyika. Aside from the “parody” part, this is exactly what Stanley was going for. He was not English, he was not a gentleman, it’s unlikely he was unruffled, but he assumed a real gentleman would be. Like a nerd trying to dress up as a cool kid, Stanley blundered just when he was trying to be most careful.
Stanley wasn’t an Englishman, but he also wasn’t an American. Stanley was a crypto-Welshman, probably one of very few in modern history. He wasn’t even a Stanley! John Rowlands, his birth name, was born illegitimate in Denbigh/Dinbych, Wales. Neither of his parents wanted anything to do with him, so he was raised by various extended family members until he was five, when he got shunted to the workhouse. It was a hellish Dickensian existence, and first chance he got Rowlands skipped town, sailing to America to reinvent himself, as was the custom of the time. He changed his name to Henry Morton Stanley, created a fake biography, served on both sides of the US Civil War, and became a yellow journalist. Throughout it all he was at pains to conceal his Welsh heritage, his illegitimacy, his unloving family, and his impoverished upbringing (while also concealing from the people who’d known him in Wales the fact that he’d abandoned his ancestral name and national origins). As you can imagine, when Stanley became one of the most famous people of his day, this double deceit became increasingly difficult. But perhaps such things were easier in the nineteenth century.
iii. Despite the “presume” gaffe, Stanley’s expedition to find (and succor) Dr. Livingstone changed his life, and overwhelmingly positively. It brought him fame and fortune, of course, but Livingstone also provided Stanley with an inspiration, a role model, and a father figure. Stanley talked and wrote about Livingstone obsessively, and in his accounts, Livingstone’s complicated legacy becomes subsumed by a portrait of a modern-day saint. Stanley would spend the rest of his life working not only in Africa but for Africa, and, to be more precise, for Africans.
Stanley has gotten a bad rap over the years, starting in his lifetime, and over more serious things than “Dr. Livingstone, I presume.” Stanley was his own worst enemy here. His background in yellow journalism persuaded him to embellish his adventures, to make what must have been some of the most exciting journeys of all time more exciting. Stanley knew, or thought he knew, what the public wanted: They wanted blood! He had cut his teeth reporting in the Wild West on gunslingers and Indian attacks. When out West, Stanley, a bit of a secret soft heart, had peppered his stories with pleas for better treatment of Native Americans, easily alternating liberal sentiment and gore. This was a simple enough juxtaposition: After all, the violence was coming from everyone except our humble reporter Stanley. But in Africa, if there was going to be bloodshed, Stanley was likely to be in the thick of it! And in his articles Stanley dutifully dialed up the bloodshed, even if that required some invention. Stanley was nothing if not a serial inventor.
Doubtless some of his readers lapped this carnage up—but not everyone was so happy. Counterintuitive as it may seem now, in the late nineteenth century, especially in England, there was a real solicitousness about the lives of Black Africans. The Saturday Review thundered against the spectacle of “a private American citizen” trespassing on someone else’s land and killing locals “with no sanction, no authority, no jurisdiction—nothing but explosive bullets and a copy of the Daily Telegraph.” Stanley was not a soldier or a government official. He was just some dude, strolling around Africa getting into fights. He wasn’t even British!
Of course he was in fact British, but only secretly.
And so, as the lone American in Central Africa, Stanley found himself with no allies among the explorers and colonial officials. He was not traveling under the flag of an Imperial power (I guess there was Liberia, but Stanley didn’t go to Liberia). Other explorers may have been impressed by his ability to trek long distances through Africa and not die, but they didn’t really respect him.
He could have torn off his false nose and whiskers and revealed himself to be a Welshman—he could have tried to ally himself with his fellow Britons. But his real Welsh past was too embarrassing, and he had told too many lies about his fake American past to make this easy.
Which wouldn’t have been so bad, except Stanley decided he wanted to end slavery in Africa.
“Look at me, I’m Welsh!” → Britain loves its Stanley → Leopold gets scooped in the Congo → That’s several million fewer people murdered
Mr. Stanley, I presume.
•Sheridan, School for Scandal (1777).
It would be inaccurate to present Stanley as an enlightened, twenty-first-century type. By any modern standard he was clearly racist. But compared to other nineteenth-century African explorers, Stanley was as progressive as they come. Perhaps uniquely among his peers, Stanley really liked Africans, and they in turn liked him. This was part of his success as an explorer: He could use the same guides, porters, and arms-bearers for mission after mission (instead of recruiting a new, soon-to-be-disgruntled crew each time). Because his men (comparatively) rarely deserted, he could bring fewer and travel lighter. He forbade them to steal from the villages they passed (although, if one of his men did get caught stealing by the locals, he would offer to bail the thief out). He spoke to his men in Swahili, and paid bonuses to the widows of those who died en route. Not all explorers would arrange for their bearer’s transport home from wherever the expedition ended up, which could be a real pickle, if you think about it—but Stanley did.
Ending slavery is challenging, as the history of America will give witness. The British general Charles George Gordon devoted the last years of his life to eliminating slavery in Egypt and the Sudan; realizing that a declaration banning slavery would be ignored and cause an uprising, Gordon proposed to gradually phase slavery out in these territories between 1877 and 1889. They rose up anyway. Biographer Demetrius Boulger imagined Gordon responding to “arm-chair reformers” who were unhappy with the gradual approach, vowing to take any steps necessary: “I will [Boulger makes Gordon say] break the neck of slave raids, even if it cost me my life.” It cost him just that, and he didn’t even make it to 1889.
Stanley also dreamed of ending slavery in Africa, having seen first-hand the cruelty of the Arab-Swahili slavers. And Stanley had a plan: to develop Central Africa by building railroad tracks into the interior. Central Africans could export crops, skins, minerals, and rubber to the West, so there would be no need for them to sell slaves. Presumably, furthermore, the blessings of civilization would make slavery wither on the vine. If that sounds overly optimistic to you, consider that at the very least it would be easier for European powers to forbid slavery through force if their armed representatives were always hopping on steam locomotives and trading throughout the continent.
In order to ensure that there was no corruption or graft in this plan of development, Stanley figured he could create a purely philanthropic non-profit organization to run the show. All he needed was a financial backer.
But the one thing Stanley did not have was friends among the imperial powers. Who was this American to present empires with his crazy schemes?
It was a miracle that Stanley found a backer at all, but he did, a guy who would bankroll the project and then make Stanley, solemn promise, the first governor of the resulting state.
Tragically that backer was the single worst human for the job: Belgium’s King Leopold II.
ii. “My God!” Clarence Darrow once orated, “this world has been one long slaughter house from the beginning until today, and killing goes on and on and on, and will forever.” Some people would think that’s excessively cynical, but perhaps they’d be happier to describe the history of colonial adventurism in Africa as “one long slaughter house.” Well, not happier, necessarily, but more willing. Laying out the supporting evidence for such an abattoir would be, as I’ve said before in another context, too easy to be interesting and too depressing to be fun, so let’s take one example that affected (and outraged) Stanley personally. A lieutenant on his final expedition, James Jameson (heir to the whiskey fortune), had bought a slave, an eleven-year old girl, for the sole purpose of handing her over to cannibals so he could observe her murder and consumption, all while sketching the proceedings in his notebook. Jameson died (the death rates of African explorers (and their porters) were high) soon after. You can find Snopes chewing over the accuracy of this story here.
Stanley blamed the situation, and implicitly himself for placing Jameson in it. After all, had Jameson stayed in Britain he would hardly have become a murderer. But here in Africa, as Stanley lamented in his diary, “deprived of butcher’s meat & bread & wine, books, newspapers, the society & influence of [his] friends…good nature was banished by anxiety.” In fact, Jameson had also been responsible for the deaths of a hundred or so other Africans, whom he had literally worked to death—he refused to give them sufficient time to prep the manioc tubers they ate, and improperly prepared manioc is poisonous. Driven by hunger, they’d been forced to eat the stuff raw and risk death.
But whatever evil Jameson wrought in Africa, it was small potatoes compared to the evil slavery wrought in Africa. The transatlantic slave trade was kaput, and the Ottoman Empire had banned the importation of slaves in 1857—but the Ottomans no longer had much power even in the parts of Arabia they nominally held, and slaves still made their way across the Red Sea, as well as being traded internally by African potentates. Nineteenth century explorers are consistent in their declaration of how ruinous the lingering slave trade was to Africa. Thomas Parke (Stanley’s medical officer), notes that one slaver of repute, Ungarrowwa (Parke spells the name Ugarrowwa), had “certainly spread desolation all around this part of the country; we every day pass by ruined villages, the natives of which have all been chased away, or destroyed.” Stanley, coming upon a village after Ungarrowwa had been there, found that the man’s forces “had burnt the settlement…and strewed the ground with the bones of the defenders. Five skulls of infants were found within our new camp at Navabi.”
Twenty years before, Ungarrowwa had been a “tent boy” on a British search for what people used to call the caput Nili, but had deserted in Central Africa. Deserting hundreds of miles from home as he did was usually a death sentence for native porters, but somehow instead Ungarrowwa (in the words of Stanley’s biographer Tim Jeal) “made a fortune from slaves and ivory. Ungarrowwa had killed most of the adult males in the land surrounding his settlement, and had enslaved their women for the harems of Arabia. The male children had been ‘indoctrinated as menials & foot soldiers.’” This is an impressive achievement in its own way, but it’s also an incredibly sad and terrifying story. Had the slave trade not offered a path to wealth and power, would Ungarrowa, like Jameson, ever have become a monster?
And so getting rid of the slave trade seems like an unambiguously good idea. Stanley, who knew more about Central Africa than any European alive, was the obvious choice for supervising construction on the infrastructure to reach the heart of the Congo. He was also the obvious choice to be made governor of the resulting state, so he could ensure that it ran free from corruption and atrocity.
The only hitch in the plan was Leopold, who gave Stanley the first of these jobs and, despite all his promises, denied him the second; Leopold, who despite a steady diet of butcher’s meat & bread & wine ended up a monster.
iii. What do I know about Leopold II? More than I know about any other Belgian king and yet also very little. I’ve never read a biography of him, nor anything he himself wrote. But no one has ever absolved him of what must be the central fact of his life: that his policies in the Congo Free State, of which he was the head and sole proprietor, resulted in the deaths of somewhere around five to ten million people, many of them literally worked to death in order to extract wealth, primarily rubber, from the Congo.
That wasn’t the plan, of course. Leopold had tricked Stanley into carving out an empire for him in central Africa, and he had also tricked Europe assembled into letting him keep it. His motives were philanthropical! He was going to bring light to the dark continent.
Even as Stanley (no longer in Africa, no longer an employee) began to learn about the atrocities ramping up in the Free State, his only thought was to tell Leopold. Leopold would fix it! Ah, but Leopold did not fix it, and Stanley’s association with him has only tarnished the explorer’s legacy. Even the free in Free State would prove to be a lie.
But it didn’t have to be Leopold. Britain, from the standpoint of its abolitionist history and imperial proximity was the most natural choice for charitably developing Central Africa; France the next choice. But who in Britain was going to listen to a man who was not only not Welsh but who had launched a public campaign to raise awareness of the fact that he was not (despite some rumors) Welsh?
Stanley came back from his Livingstone expedition an international hero; but not a British hero. He rëenheroized himself several times in the years after that, most notably in “pulling a Livingstone” a second time by finding (and succoring) one of Charles George Gordon’s regional governors, left isolated in the interior (after Gordon had been killed over the whole abolition thing). But although he eventually became a British citizen (through marriage) and even served in Parliament (!)—that all happened too late for the corridors of power to step in ahead of Leopold.
Imagine the history of the Congo if a proudly Welsh Stanley (“sure, I went to America to seek my fortune, but it was always Old Blighty that called to me etc. etc. Cymru forever! etc.”) handed over Central Africa to Great Britain. A history of Rhodesia etc. will caution us that a British protectorate in Africa will not preclude atrocities, but one thing about the Belgian Congo as it went in our history…it perhaps literally could not have gone worse. And the British Congo State would not be under the auspices of Cecil Rhodes, but rather of Henry Stanley. Henry Stanley really wanted to make life better in Central Africa! He wasn’t faking it for profit!
It’s very easy and tempting for me to end a chapter in nuclear annihilation; I’m temperamentally less inclined towards visions of a benign fate. Colonial Africa sucked, and it was historically easy for even a progressive colony to “backslide”—before 1892, Black men in South Africa could vote! Probably the Congo would have a hard road into the twentieth century even without Leopold.
But if there’s a hard road and then there’s a hard road that does not start with five to ten million citizens being murdered. Whatever destiny the Congo would reach in 2022, it would be [fill in the blank here with something sweeter and better].

(I rely here heavily on Tim Jeal’s rehabilitative biography Stanley: The Impossible Life of Africa's Greatest Explorer (Faber & Faber, 2007); the other biography of Stanley I read—Richard Seymour Hall, Stanley: An Adventurer Explored (Houghton Mifflin, 1975)—is much less bullish on Stanley, and should probably be consulted as an antidote. 1977 joke book: Phil Hirsch & Paul Laikin, Women’s Libbers and Male Chauvinists (Pyramid, 1977) cover & p. 50; “Oh, what a shocking bad hat you have got!”: Mackay, op cit., pp. 621ff.; Paul Johnson, The Birth of the Modern (HarperCollins, 1991) p. 534; The Saturday Review: Jeal p. 225; Darrow: Nina Barrett, The Leopold and Loeb Files (Midway, 2018) p. 218; “deprived of butcher’s meat”: Jeal p. 358; Thomas Heazle Parke, My Personal Experiences in Equatorial Africa As Medical Officer of the Emin Pasha Relief Expedition (Scribner’s Sons, 1891) p. 112; “had burnt the settlement”: Stanley, In Darkest Africa vol. I (Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1891) p. 203; “made a fortune from slaves and ivory”: Jeal p. 340.)


